« 10 Tips For Greener Living | Main | How To Earn Forgiveness And Rebuild Trust After Betrayal »

The Biggest Loser--Wrong About The Need To Cheat

TONY DEAN, known as The Meanest Man of Dieting, and the author of The F.A.S.T. Diet (Families Always Succeed Together) lives with his family in Omaha, Nebraska. After the Dean family of eight had lost 500 pounds, they decided to make an impact on their community and helped a group from their home city lose 4,000 pounds. Now the Dean family is taking this crusade from city to city, helping people lose weight using The F.A.S.T Diet.

Guest Blogger Tony Dean--

Like most people I love the show "The Biggest Loser," especially how it demonstrates how hard one must work out to lose weight. What I don’t understand is how such a seemingly credible source can sometimes give such terrible advice. On the last show, Bob Harper, who I respect completely said something like, “On The Biggest Loser we have a cheat day after each weigh in to shock the body and recharge the metabolism.” Sounds great right?j0422355.jpg

This comment was wrong in so many ways, but as a viewer I can only imagine that it made perfect sense – let me explain. The average dieter is already a professional cheater and has spent an entire life cheating on exercise and food. One of the biggest obstacles dieters have to overcome is the creation of new positive patterns that includes consistent exercise and improved food choices. Experts say a habit takes at least 14 days to form, how can interrupting this process every 7 days make sense? It doesn’t. By choosing this strategy you never get a chance to permanently learn the discipline of control. Instead, you are just buying time to get to your next cheat.

But let’s say for a minute he’s dead on. The way this cheat day was characterized was a free-for-all. There was no instruction on how little or how much to cheat. Most people dieting are hanging on by a thread. Encouraging a cheat day would be like offering an alcoholic a drink once a week because he has remained sober. I think that since 10.1 million people watch the show it might have been prudent to say, “Eat an additional 1000 calories” or whatever else they meant. As a result, I assure you, there are thousands of people thinking, “What a great idea, I will make my cheat day, today.” Due to this huge error, "today" will probably be the last day they diet successfully THIS YEAR!

On the same show they said the participants workout as much as 6 hours a day. How can their strategy compare in any way to yours? Having a cheat day for them may make perfect sense in those conditions; certainly though, you are not working out 6 hours a day and you definitely don’t have the accountability they have in place either. It is amazing to me that with all their doctors and specialists, they can give this kind of advice and not see its detrimental effect to the watching public.

When I wrote my book, The F.A.S.T. Diet, I wanted to make it about real life and how to overcome real life situations consistently--showing how to lose the weight fast, while mastering the stills you will need to maintain. After that you can enjoy the rest of your life without having to count on tips and tricks that may or may not work. Last year we helped 100 volunteers use our program and they lost 4000 lbs. Now groups are springing up all over the country using our simple plan mixed in with an ironclad accountability program that will help you get past the next piece of horrible advice. Remember, The Biggest Loser is a TV show, what we teach is how to make this happen in Reality!

Don’t lose focus, you can do it!

More From Tony Dean--Dieting Is All Or Nothing!

PrintView Printer Friendly Version

EmailEmail Article to Friend

Reader Comments (4)

I am a recent "Cabbage Soup Diet" sufferer, and would just like to warn the thousands of women that are even considering this method to shed pounds to stay far away from it. In a nutshell, I stayed true to its recipe for successful weight loss, and came out of it with health risks and only 3 pounds lost. If you don't take my word for it you can read much more on the origin and effects of the cabbage soup diet at the reference below.


http://cabbagesoupdiet.wikidot.com/
March 17, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterMichelle Dunn
Tony, I have to respectfully disagree with you, to an extent. I hear what you're saying about encouraging lifestyle changes, and your analogy about giving an alcoholic a drink once a week to recognize his sobriety is an excellent one.

However, Bob isn't the only person I've heard say this. I have been on the Body For Life plan, and I've dropped from 258 to 219 lbs. The BFL plan has a "free day", too. They don't call it "cheat day", only because they say you should be "free" to eat good or eat bad. But yeah, I feel "free" to eat bad on that day.

Where I will agree with you 100% is the lack of clarification on the cheat/free eating. Without any guidance, the takeaway message is "I can gorge all day long", and in the beginning, that's what I did. It was like "I only get this day for another week, so I should eat as much as I can before the weekly window closes!"

I still lost weight every week, but I plateaued. Once I modified my free day (six small cheat meals instead of three huge ones and several sugar-loaded snacks throughout the day, even when I wasn't hungry), the weight loss resumed.

I eat tasty, healthy foods all week long: Pumpkin protein pancakes made with whole grain flour, no sugar, and sugar-free syrup; jerk pork chops (lean cuts, with a black bean and no-sugar-added pineapple confit; breakfast burritos made with whole-grain low-carb tortillas, Egg Beaters, mushrooms, and Canadian bacon. Those taste fantastic, and I don't feel deprived.

But I also love pizza. I love certain fried foods. I love sugary desserts. Once I week, I indulge in small portions of those, and my weight loss hasn't been negatively affected from it.

I don't think a cheat meal or a cheat day is bad, provided that it is done sensibly. Just my $0.02 worth.
April 17, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterJonathan Leffingwell
Jonathan,
Thank you so much for this comment. What I think you are describing as a cheat day, in our diet we call ... Every Day! If you read my book you will not only find that no foods are off limits (although better choices are encouraged), instead we take a real life approach and say, "If you like chocolate, then eat chocolate, just fit it in your calories for the day."

Bob's comments was so open ended that a 60 year old woman who needs 1400 calories a day might think that a 3500 calorie cheat day could work for her. These kind of irresponsible remarks cost dieters years of their lives both in number and comfort.

Thanks again for the comment and congrats on your loss.

Tony, 402-214-7788, fastdiet@cox.net
April 17, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterTony Dean
Hi Michelle,

Sorry to hear about your Cabbage Diet fiasco. I hope you know this is not that. People across the nation are taking our approach and their doctors are thrilled. Our approach is real life, practical and effective. Check out the book.

Tony
www.thefastdiet.net
April 17, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterTony Dean

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.